Chevy Astro and GMC Safari Forum banner

Power Window Regulator Combo Question

2 reading
501 views 19 replies 4 participants last post by  Gabor Latte  
#1 · (Edited)
Hi. My front passenger window rolls down lickety-split, but recently rolls up super-duper slow. I’ve already tried lubricating the sides, but it didn’t make a dent. I’m all but positive it’s gonna go from slow to no-go soon enough, and wanna be proactive about it. Not sure if there’s any option left other than to….replace….the motor…or regulator? Being as I don’t know which is at fault, I figure I’d get the combo to play both sides, and it's cheaper than the two units sold separately and I'd rather take the door off just this once. But I don’t see many people talking about such a dual-device, let alone a step-by-step instructional regarding how to replace the old motor and regulator with the combo. One question is: does the motor part of it attach to the same place as the old motor? Will it all become obvious, like a jigsaw puzzle, when I'm eyeballing it? I guess my most basic, burning question is: can someone with little-to-no experience in this particular area be able to do the switcharoo? I know that meddling inside the little metal caves behind the door can even try the patience of a seasoned mechanic. But it’s absurdly expensive to have an auto shop do it compared to DIY...

EDIT: This product here is what I'm calling "the combo":

Please pardon any delay in response. Am off-grid and internet's sparse. Thanks.
 
#4 · (Edited)
I did mine on both sides,driver and passenger doors, on the 1990..I believe the motor and regulator were one unit that unplugs easily and unhooks from the rollup framework..It's a matter of taping the window in the up closed position (duct tape down onto the glass on both sides over a piece of cardboard that protected the painted surfaces, bent over the top of the door in the open position).. you need to drill out three rivets and replace them with short bolts and lock nuts( or nuts and lockwashers) in the same holes when you put the new motors in and have the connections to the rods reconnected.I didn't think it was too complicated or expensive to do by oneself,as a backyard mechanic with basic tools..couple wrenches,drill and bits,small socket set.Like I said..the wiring clips on and off..1/4" x 1/2" bolts in the old drilled out rivet holes..

I also sprayed wd40 down the side tracks and used a stick and rag to clean the racks out well..I don't think it was enough to fix the problem but something that should be done while one has the door panel off anyway..besides lubing everything else while you are there.

You need to remove the inner door panel..get one of the tools for that for about $10-12 at O'Reily's that pull out the Christmas tree type push-on connector pins that hold the panel on after you take out a few screws in the upper portion (door handle attachment).

The lower half has the pins(your year van might be slightly different for attachment,but will be obvious what needs to be removed,like wires for door speakers? (Don't know if your year had speakers in the doors..)....and then disconnect the wiring for the switches and.?...the panel is pushed up off the inner piece at the top of the panel at the window point. There will be a plastic or paper insulator/liner you need to try and remove carefully behind the panel Tape any spots that tear,etc..when you put it back on..

Before you put the door panel back on,test the up and down(after removing the tape on the glass of course)....make sure there aren't other problems.

Take note of the window rods that help the window go up and down(take pictures?) and how things clip together..

I think I had a small screw or rivet out of one of the lower corners of the track holding it in one spot inline(the track would flex and move there)..was an easy fix with a new screw or bolt.

I thought I took some pics..can't find them now.. anyway..instructions from a 1990 service manual.NOTE THE STEP 2 CAUTION on "replacing the motor portion" about putting a small bolt in to lock the gear..
Image
 
#5 ·
realityguy, good write up. Sounds about how I replaced it on my 01, previous owner had replaced it once, and reinstalled with tiny machine screws, trying to remove the tiny nuts off the back off them I wondered what the heck was he thinking installing the window motor in such a way. When I installed the new motor I just riveted it on like the factory had done the originals, so much easier than fiddling with a machine screw in there, if it needs to be done again I'll drill out the rivet, but I dont need to worry about the nuts coming loose this way
 
#6 ·
Wow, indeed that was a good comprehensive write up. Thanks for all of that, which filled in some gaps in my overall understanding.

I had messaged the seller of that combo rig on Amazon, asking if the motor part of the combo sat in the same place as the motor-only unit. They said..."no, it doesn't". So I'm still trying to understand exactly how/where this combo unit is connected. I was hoping it was just your standard-issue motor and regulator...that just happen to be connected. But I guess it's not that simple, and so I still don't understand where the motor part is supposed to be installed. Do you remember where the motor part got hitched to the door, realityguy?
 
#7 · (Edited)
Sorry it took so long to get back to you..LOL!..it's 1am here and I was up for other reasons..Anyway..I thought I kept the old units..and I found them..pics attached. I believe they were this one below in the link.. Note the plug on the end of the regulator(?) has the wires sticking out. It might be dettachable and sold as a separate item but I didn't want to get into that(for the price)..and by the pieces separate and have one piece still be bad..or go bad because it wasn't changed out.
It might have been this one on ebay--->


It looks the same as the AC Delco ones I took out. I replaced them "one piece" because I really didn't want to do it again!

I don't remember which side the picture one was (same looking), but they were both kind of slow..so I did both of them (the wire colors should tell on that one pictured).

I also found I had broken wires in the wire looms in the door jambs so did all the work at one time..
Pic..
Image


Yeah..I keep a lot of my old parts..when I go to sell the van I can say "here's what I replaced"..hard to argue with that!..and they are good for reference later..like this thread..LOL!

As far as the "mount area on the door"..same obvious spot as the crank style one would be I assume,..near the top..of course gear goes inward. The small lines "might " be where the rivets were... maybe 4? Once you get the panel off there is only one place it can go. I think I read some where that the regulator controls up and down so with the window all the way up and taped in the up closed position..you mount them on the door frame and they are set correctly..the regulator automatically stops at the top and bottom max points (by pressure?).

Looking at it again..I believe the tracks aren't attached to the motor except with the gear in place..but check and lubricate the points the track bars connect to each other.. The other ebay ads in that same search show the motors with the full tracks one can purchase (search was "1990 Astro power window motor")..if you want to see the other ads..ads with and without the track rods)

Amazon?..JUST MY OPINION>>>I don't buy anything from Amazon anymore since a lot of those sellers only have seen/possess pictures of the products they sell (parts/orders sent from/to a separate selling-to-seller warehouse they deal with. The seller doesn't have the part ) I had a seller that sold me a micro circuit pressure sensor I needed badly for a septic tank pump setup..and a seller wanted me to wait two months for the Back-ordered part instead of returning my money...neg for the seller,harassment for weeks,etc towards me in my emailbox..Good bye Amazon!

Okay..so I can't flush the toilet for two months at that house? :eek:..I found another part..I think in Switzerland..not on Amazon.
 
#8 · (Edited)
Okay..My Bad! 7AM..MY confusion with the regulator verses the window motor itself (Names of parts)..The picture is kind of vague as to what they call what..and THEY DON'T HAVE ANY PICTURE OF THE POWER WINDOW MOTOR. I assume this is the crank one shown....in the service manual OR the Electrical Diagrams book..only this single picture below. The electrical book only shows harnesses in the details shot,no components. The regulator includes the window lifting bars and that..which in my case and more than likely most others..was fine in my van..other than lube needed. I didn't need to replace any of that..just the motor portion with whatever is electrical in the connection area at the end of it..

A search on ebay shows the 'regulator portion can be bought seperately..if needed..

This is what is given in the SM... and that's it! You might find some better shots on youtube since a lot of the motors have needed work(replacement) on astros..
Image

Here..check these out..a real picture is better than a 100 words..

 
#9 · (Edited)
Hi. It's me now who's sorry for the late response - haven't had any internet. And I might be sorry about one other thing too: In my original post, I had written "I figure I’d get the combo to play both sides", and I had inserted this hyperlink, as I just did now again. But I just glanced at my original post, and there's no hyperlink! And it was that link - to the amazon product page - that I was thinking carried a lot of weight/info of what my query was really about - which is that specific product or design, which I have been calling "the combo". But meanwhile maybe you and maybe everyone else didn't know what I was exactly talking about. I wanted any intel as to how to install it, or if it was difficult or notably any different - if the motor part fit differently, in a different location - than the isolated motor and isolated regulator. That was the whole point of my post. And so I'm really unsure still if you have been talking about this "combo". From the photos, I'm thinking maybe not? If not - jeez, I'm so sorry to confuse you and waste your time!
 
#10 ·
Ok I think I get what you're asking. There is a window motor and a window regulator, you can buy either separate or you can buy them already attached to each other. If you only need one or the other you only have to buy one or the other, or you can buy both pre connected to each other.

These are not two different types of setups, if you bought just the motor and swapped it, the assembly would still be exactly the same thing as you are getting with them as a unit.

The motor bolts or rivets to the regulator and they fit inside of the door between the inner and outer sheet metal. It should be pretty obvious how to do it when you pull it apart. I only changed my motor, I have changed regulators before but not on this van, but it won't be too complex.

I have my door panels off right now and can snap a pic or two tomorrow if you like
 
#11 ·
"They are not two different types of setups". This is what I'm really trying to determine - I'd they are fundamentally set up differently. Because, as mentioned, I'd messaged that combo rig seller on Amazon, asking "does the motor part of the combo sit in the same place as the motor-only unit?". They replied, "no, it doesn't". They actually contacted their tech dept to get me that answer. Still, something could've be lost in translation. But this is why I'm trying to find someone who has actually installed one of these combo units, or has a great comprehensive grasp on the general field of Astro window motors and regulators installation.
 
#12 ·
I had a post written up but having to sign in again. lost it in the process. GRRR...Basically..The link..50% of the pictures are wrong for an astro,the door panel on the assembly line isn't an astro one..The first picture is not an astro regulator and motor.,.see the last one! The video has nothing to do with an Astro. "plastic and steel comment"..okay..truth in advertising?..Don't they normally list contents by how much is in there..most to least?

Van again..mentioned the inner metal door panel that everything mounts to...same in all auto doors,,that typically have holes appropriately placed for getting hands and parts through for mounting them.

The seller buys the picture and auction writeup from a warehouse..They have more than likely(or even want to) never seen anything more than the outside of the box..or the order is shipped direct from the warehouse somewhere else,never in the seller's hand.items returned go the the warehouse..maybe in China...(Go ahead..i dare you to ask him a question!..see what kind of answer you get. After reading the post above..I see you tried.LOL!) If it doesn't mount the same way and place..how do you calculate where it goes? I would assume the tech is wrong and they mount in the same holes you just drilled out. Note certain holes in the motor mount are drilled out as are the regulator ones..and probably bolt together there on the metal panel..or that is across a hole in the inner metal door panel.

IMO..I wouldn't buy it..I'm wondering about the quality of the bearing/rollers,plastic parts, and the strength of the stamped arms of the regulator.

If you have a door panel off inside your van..check out the quality (and condition of yours) of the AC Delco set (more likely AC D)..compare it to what you see in the Amazon ad.. Again..you may decide that regulator portion is okay,once you look it over well.

Are your window felts okay?..(the outer rubber seal at the bottom of the window on the outside that holds water out). If they still have a good seal and not cracked into sections..more than likely what is inside is okay...other than a worn out motor.

I'd check that out before I'd buy anything ..if possible.
 
#13 ·
Seller probably doesn't know anything about parts.

Go over to rock auto and scroll through the listings to see what options they have too, it's good cuz you can compare all the prices and specs.

But ya, buy the motor, buy the regular, bolt the two together and you have you "combo unit"

it's the same thing not something different.
 
#16 ·
#17 ·
“The first picture is not an astro regulator and motor.,.see the last one! The video has nothing to do with an Astro.”

I grant you they might be using stock photos. The video is simply a general ad for their combo units for different vehicles, and says as much in it. Apparently these kinds of units are what the company specializes in. I take stock and comfort in the review rating average, which is good. And while I try to buy locally and am adverse to contributing to the Bezos monopoly, Amazon works works good in certain situations, especially if I might need to return it no questions asked.

“If it doesn't mount the same way and place..how do you calculate where it goes?”
That’s a damn good question, pretty much what I’ve been asking. “I would assume the tech is wrong and they mount in the same holes you just drilled out.” I’m thinking you’re right - where the heck else would it go?

“Are your window felts okay?” They felt okay to me - at least if you mean what I can access along the accessible sides.

“But ya, buy the motor, buy the regular, bolt the two together and you have you "combo unit”.
But half the inspiration for this combo unit here is to save money, and the combo’s cheaper.

“Check out this thread for a year close to yours.” Thanks for that.
 
#19 ·
“But ya, buy the motor, buy the regular, bolt the two together and you have you "combo unit”.
But half the inspiration for this combo unit here is to save money, and the combo’s cheaper.

I think you missed my point, as far as I can understand this whole post is about weather buying the two parts preassembled as "the combo unit" as you call it is somehow some completely different part. What I was telling you is if you buy the two parts and bolt them together it will be the same thing as your "combo unit"

I don't care how you buy it, that's not what I was telling you, as long as you buy the one that is for safari/astro it is the same thing.

On rock auto the dorman unit motor/regulator looks to be ten dollars more than buying the motor and buying the regulator then bolting them together yourself. Again where and how you purchase it is your business, I just letting you know it's the same parts.
 
#18 ·
Either way..if you buy that set..let us..and in the future,others.. know how it worked out. It could be a good deal/set at a cheap price.

With mine..the regulator portion was okay;I just lubed things up..and everything works well. If your door panel is off..I'd check wires and other things also(run a second wire from the switch to the motor?..check voltage through the wires,etc..) and see if that fixes the problem....since you are right there.

Taking the panel off..really isn't a major task,especially if you do have to do it a second time.The hardest thing is lining up the Christmas tree connectors to the holes to snap them back in place..

One thing I would buy first when working with the inside door panels is this tool or something similar for messing with the connectors(working them out, realigning them from the edge over their holes,etc..)..it helps a LOT!

Heavy Duty Door Panel Plastic Fastener Remover Body Retainer Clip Pry Tool | eBay

There are several different styles and types..basically you put the fork under the panel and around the fastener,either fulcrum or twist the fork head left/ right to pull /work them out and not break them. If you break or need new ones..they are cheap on ebay for a lot more than what you can get for a few bucks at auto parts stores for only a few of them.
 
#20 · (Edited)
“Either way..if you buy that set..let us..and in the future,others.. know how it worked out. It could be a good deal/set at a cheap price.”
Ya, for sure will report my findings!

Thanks for your tips, reality guy, regards tool for the connectors. I’ve actually taken this door off several times, as have apparently previous owners. By now, many things are stripped or half-missing (like, some connectors), but enough of the right screws attach to keep the door connected all-told, but I don’t feel the need to have it all prim and proper.

“I’m just letting you know it's the same parts". Yeah. This makes most sense all along now with hindsight from both of you guys’ inputs on this post. Last month I was scratching my head looking at the combo as maybe a whole different kind of animal. But it’s the same animal(s), it seems, only with an extra bone connecting the different body parts (not a perfect analogy I know).

Due to my plans the next few weeks or months, It’ll be hard to hunker down with this unless necessity dictates it so. The window rolls down fast, and rolls up wicked slow, but it’s not had this same behavior for several months, and hasn’t changed or died. I feel a bit more confident that, should it conk out, I’ll order the combo and do my best to install it myself. Am gonna be without internet the next 8 days, but will respond to any messages when I return to cyberland.